Saturday, March 28, 2020

On "All a Dream" BS

Good morning. I’m here to tell you that I’m terrified. In other news, I didn’t sleep well Thursday night because I had a terrible dream (I woke up thinking that someone was screaming), but I’m hoping that it means I wake up to a more productive weekend? Maybe? Not sure how that would even work, but let’s stay optimistic, shall we?

Also I’m still open to suggestions for my ‘Stay At Home’ Masterpost so if you’ve got something you think people should check out.

This was originally going to be an essay about Corona-19, but I’m depressed enough as it is. In summary of the essay that would have been:

-This sux.
-I’m anxious.
-Don’t touch me.
-I’m allergic to pollen.
-Job market is garbage, thanks for asking.
-I’m tired of apocalyptic events.

Anyhow!

---

“All a Dream” BS

So in case you don’t know, I’ve been watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer since college because I’d never seen it before and I thought it was one of the most influential television shows ever made. I made a Tumblr blog for it (yetanotherbuffyblog, if you’re interested), though it’s not being updated right now because I’m off of Tumblr for Lent. And I’ll admit that watching has been slow, in part because I wasn’t very motivated, and then it got taken down from Netflix, and then I moved away from the library I used to get the DVD’s from.

But now it legally streams for free on Facebook so I started making an effort to keep going. And I’m currently on the tail end of Season Six.

There’s an episode towards the end of the sixth season in which, through [waves hands] magic shenanigans, Buffy is getting flashes of another life, in which it seems like she’s actually in a mental asylum and that all of her adventures as we’d seen them throughout the entire series, are actually a massive web of hallucinations that she’d built up. Obviously, she chooses to go forward with her life as the Slayer, because there’s another season and several sequel comics, but the episode actually leaves it ambiguous as to whether or not the other world was real.

Whedon himself refuses to give an answer to the audience, though one of the show’s producers (who didn’t write this episode, it should be noted) claims that of course it’s fake, because this show is all about female empowerment and the idea that this is all in Buffy’s head detracts from that theme. 

Talking with my Whedon Consultant, we discussed our thoughts on this episode. He believed that it was way too late in the show’s run to pull the rug out from under us and make us seriously think that this was all a hallucination. I agreed, but I also thought that it was a really weird idea for a hallucination: in part because Buffy’s underlying character has always just wanted to be a normal person, not the Slayer, but mainly because most of the characters and events in her life had no counterparts in the asylum. All her friends, all her fights, all the drama, all the walking around--it’s apparently just something she dreamed up while being confined to a padded room? That doesn’t make that much sense to me? It’s not that she’s imagining her life is actually this big adventure, it’s that apparently it’s all a dream.

And okay, let me get to the point I set out to make: the whole idea of ending the story with a “It’s all a dream!” scenario is almost always an incredibly lazy cop-out. You shouldn’t use it.

Admittedly, I tend to be more lenient on examples where it isn’t clear whether or not it is a dream. The Buffy is egregious because we’re already five or six years into the show’s run, so handwaving it as a dream is… well, if it is a dream, we’d hardly care that much because we’re already invested in the story and characters. But in examples like El laberinto del fauno (YES I used the Spanish title for Pan’s Labyrinth, get over it) the movie doesn’t tell you it’s all in this little girl’s imagination: it’s up to you to interpret whether you think it is or not.

And if it happens partway through a story, that’s okay too! There’s a brilliant episode of Person of Interest that, partway through the episode, reveals that what we’ve seen is a simulation of what might happen being run by the Machine, who goes back and runs through it again. Or there’s the comic The Dreamer, in which Beatrice is going back and forth from life into the dreams where there are two continuous storylines: one in the modern day, the other in the American Revolution.

Then there’s that interesting episode of Batman: The Animated Series in which Bruce gets the life he’s always wanted, but it turns out to be a dream made by Mad Hatter. But in that case, we know from watching the episode that there’s something not quite right throughout the story, that something is off and we’re trying to figure out what it is. In that case, it makes sense that it’s a dream because it fits with the information we’ve already been presented.

But if at the end of a story, for the author to say, “Welp, actually none of it was real! It was a dream! Or a hallucination!” as a cheap twist ending, it devalues the story. The author didn’t commit to the story he or she was telling. It’s a trick to say, “All of that? Well it didn’t actually matter!” And it’s a bit difficult to not feel ripped off when the author is straight-up telling you that everything you cared about didn’t happen and didn’t matter.

This is, in large part, why I’m against the theory of Assassin’s Creed fans that everything that happened in-series was actually a simulation? The main story now seems to be leaning that direction, which I’m not a huge fan of, though I don’t quite know where they’re going with it, as the characters themselves seem to be becoming aware of it and that’s a whole ‘nother creature altogether.

[I’ve also seen this used as a sort of retcon; for instance, the much derided Highlander: The Source was declared by one of the actors as just a bad dream, which, okay fair, that movie sucked. But there’s also a line in one of the straight-to-home video American Tail movies that retcons the second one into just being a dream, and that earns a slap to whoever wrote that line. I’m not a huge fan of it as a retconning device, unless it’s to erase something absolutely terrible from the continuity.]

The story should make you feel satisfied at the end. I shouldn’t reach the end of a story and say, “Wow, I got really worked up about absolutely nothing!” Which is ultimately what you’ve done if you go with this twist. If the ending of the story is telling me that I shouldn’t have gotten invested… well, that’s not a great thing to do if you want an audience to care about what you’ve written!

So don’t do it!

---

Saturday, March 21, 2020

Castlevania: Season 3 Review

I think I’m also going to do a masterpost of links to do if you’re stuck somewhere and you’re really bored.

This review has spoilers, yo.

---

Castlevania: Season 3 Review

If you’ve read my previous reviews, you know I have a bit of a rocky history with the Netflix adaptation of Castlevania. I love the animation and the action, and I like the core team of characters quite a bit. But thematically I have some issues with its overall message: on religion (which it doesn’t seem to like very much), on human nature (which it seems to like even less), and on its pacing. That last one stood out, because the first season is only four episodes and its second season is eight, and in  all of that we get both our setup and our climax, and I thought it didn’t feel that earned, especially since the heroes spent most of season two sitting in a basement doing homework. Them killing Dracula was awesome, but I didn’t get a sense that it was all building up to this moment, you know?

Season three is a bit better on its pacing, though the way that works might frustrate viewers to an extent. Because while it feels like this season gives the characters some stuff to do that isn’t rushing towards a climactic battle, at the same time… very little actual Plot development happens. Trevor and Sypha’s story doesn’t connect with anything else in a direct way, nor does Alucard’s. Isaac’s story is good overall, but the season ends before it really gets going. And Hector’s just… goes exactly where you expected from the very beginning.

And since I mentioned Hector, I’ll go into my number one problem for the season: the Plot relies on people being stupid. Hector’s in particular sticks out. After trusting Carmilla last season backfired (because OF COURSE IT DID), it seems like maybe Hector has learned his lesson, as first chance he gets he tries to hold Lenore, one of vampires on Carmilla’s council, hostage. Except after she beats the snot out of him, she keeps trying to be nice to him by talking how vampires aren’t so bad, feeding him food, getting him better living arrangements, and so on. But whenever she takes him for a walk she puts him on a leash, and when he does something she wants she tells him “Good boy!” like a dog. So at the end of the season she seduces him, and during sex gets him to swear loyalty to her, which because of black magic shenanigans binds him to her and means that he physically can’t escape. And then he’s like, “You tricked me!”

YES! The vampire woman who treats you like a pet sees you as a pet! Why would you think otherwise? Why would you have sex with her? Why would you swear loyalty while having sex with her? All of those are things that would happen only if Hector was a complete moron. Which apparently, he is.

That’s hardly the only example this season of someone being stupid, but it’s the one that sticks out. There’s also the Lindenfeld Plot, in which the deranged evil monks who worship Dracula are carving alchemical symbols on all the houses in town, but no one sees fit to try to scratch out or get rid of these marks. There’s the two Japanese vampire slayers who go to Alucard to train, only to decide that he needs to die for… Reasons? 

Leading to my next point: if the first two seasons had a low opinion of humanity, it’s even lower here. Yeah, there’s the stupidity, but the implication is that humans are just stupid to begin with, and of the few that aren’t, most of them are terrible. The finale reveals that the Judge who’d been aiding Trevor and Sypha all season, seeming to be a reasonable authority figure, was also a child serial killer, something that doesn’t affect the Plot at all except to kick you while you’re down. Isaac has a conversation with a damned soul which tells us that apparently in the Castlevania-verse, when Greece turned Christian that pagan philosophers were hunted through the streets like animals and tortured. That thinking about God was considered a crime to get you executed.

[Thomas Aquinas would like to disagree.]

I’m also really not comfortable with the show apparently hardlining this anti-Christian stance, considering we live in a world which there are violent groups of people who increasingly want us Christians dead that there’s a critically acclaimed series more or less declaring that it’s totally fine, Christians are monsters anyway so they all deserve to die. I recognize that the places where this is a big issue are generally not where this show is streamed, but it’s still a very disconcerting notion that it consistently tries to paint an entire religion as by its very nature evil.

TV Tropes’s YMMV pages tells me that I should be grateful for that one priest character who blesses some water in Season One, but let’s be real: he isn’t given a name, never shows up before or after that point, and has no lines at all. 

And while Plot’s pacing is much better, the pacing of characterization isn’t. There’s some ship tease between Trevor and Sypha in the first two seasons, but when we start Season Three they’re already in a sexual relationship, which is more than a little jarring considering we haven’t even seen them kiss before this point. It’s not just me, is it? That we’re following two of our leads, and the show’s like, “Oh, by the way, they’re sleeping together now. Is that cool?” It’s a huge bit of character development to just skip over.

Isaac’s character arc is a bit frustrating because he’s very slow to figure out why guards are upset at him marching a group of Hellspawn through their towns. There’s also a notable scene where someone tells him, “What if humans aren’t all bad and don’t all deserve to die?” and that gives Isaac some pause. Which is stupid, because you’re telling me he’s gone all this time hating humanity and wiping them out, and never once did he stop and think, “Hey maybe not all humans are terrible to everyone else all the time!”? This stoic character has never stopped and thought about what he’s doing?

Hector’s just an idiot and that’s irritating to watch.

And Alucard has Sumi and Taka to train, who then decide because he isn’t helping them as much as they want that they’ve got to seduce him into a threesome (???) and then murder him (?!?). This isn’t actually out of nowhere, as we see them talk to each other and Alucard about how he’s not sharing everything with them, and how they really want to figure out to make the castle move and he’s telling them that the mechanism is broken and he doesn’t have much interest in fixing it. But them leaping from that to seduction and murder is a leap I didn’t quite follow.

It felt many times that the series was trying very hard to be bleak and grimdark, and of course, this is Castlevania, of course it’s got to be dark. But so much of it was just pointlessly so. This wasn’t monsters killing people, this was people being dicks to each other for no discernible reason. One of the characters was an actual child serial killer, and this wasn’t a part of the story for anything except shock value. 

This season was not without its bright points; the Plot moves along much better. There are interesting new characters, like Carmilla’s council and the Count of Saint Germaine. And the action’s top notch again; the battle at the end of the season is well worth the wait. But I don’t know if it was worth the full ending, and some of the other bits of the season. I can’t help but find myself thinking that if the show is going to continue with giving us a grimdark atmosphere with plot twists like this, I can’t say I’m interested. 

I don’t care for it.

---

Stuck At Home Masterpost

If you’re stuck at home and you’re really bored, some links to look into that might cheer you up:



I'll probably expand this list as time goes on! Suggestions are welcome! 

Saturday, March 14, 2020

Best of the Decade: Part 3

Yo, welcome to Part 3! Haven’t caught the killer virus yet, but in case I do the house has been stocked with a lot of stuff, so I can be quarantined in peace. And lots of books to read too! Oh so many books…

---

Best Star Wars: Star Wars: Rebels

I had problems with the Sequel Trilogy. I’m not saying they’re bad; they’re not bad films! But individually they’ve got enough issues that I can’t say I enjoyed them more than the Disney XD animated series. The Clone Wars was good, but it didn’t start this past decade, and if it did, the fact is that the first two and half seasons of attempting to make a non-chronological anthology series was difficult to follow at times. Jedi Fallen Order is also good, very good. Maybe The Mandalorian is also great, but I’m morally against getting Disney+ so I don’t know for sure. But ultimately I give it to Rebels because DANG this was a good series. 

Mind you, it’s not a perfect series; it drops the ball on a couple of things, giving some characters the short end of the stick on arcs that should mean more (Ezra’s flirtation with the Dark Side in season three comes to mind--it only takes up like three or four episodes). But it scratches the itch I think a lot of Star Wars fans had in the Disney Era. It does everything that I feel a good spin-off should do: it’s enjoyable in its own right, it ties together different parts of the series, it takes a closer look at the themes and ideas in the story. And as a Star Wars story, it manages to be an interesting war story while also managing to going into the mysticism of the Force, animated in a way evocative of Ralph McQuarrie’s original concept art.

And the two-part season two finale, “Twilight of the Apprentice,” is one of the greatest season finales of all time, FIGHT ME.

I did not expect to love this series as much as I did when I started watching it. It has a lovable cast, it expands the mythology, and it’s a spin-off that actually works. I can’t help but think that if the Sequel Trilogy had been done by this team (and yes, I would have accepted an animated movie trilogy with that cast), then I have no doubt it would have been received with applause.

Best Remake/Reboot: Man from U.N.C.L.E.

[Is the Shadow of the Colossus remaster a remake? I dunno, but maybe go check that out too if you’re into games.]

I considered not putting this, because my sister is taking credit for too many of these already. But look, this movie is actually really good, and I’m sad that it didn’t become a smash hit when it came out. 

It’s like this: it’s the Cold War. American CIA agent Napoleon Solo (Henry Cavill) is ordered to help a German mechanic Gaby Teller (Alicia Vikander) find her father, who is currently working (under duress) for a group of Italian fascists on a bomb. To help with the mission, Solo has to team up with Russian KGB agent Ilya Kuryakin (Armie Hammer), who has to pose as Gaby’s fiance. 

And in some ways, this feels a bit like everything you ever wanted in a spy team-up movie? Or a fanfic, I guess. Enemies-to-friends? Pretending-to-be-lovers? Cool music and stylish outfits? Sarcastic humor? Teeth-clenched teamwork? It’s all there. And it’s all amazing. I’m a bit surprised that with this and with Sherlock Holmes that Guy Ritchie doesn’t have more of a reputation as being a director with his own noticeable style that has its own fanbase.

Maybe you won’t enjoy it as much as I did, but you will enjoy it, I think.

Best Prequel: Sandman: Overture written by Neil Gaiman illustrated by J.H. Williams III

I recall thinking that this was going to be a half-baked prequel that didn’t add anything to the story. And to be clear, you don’t really need to read this to understand the Sandman storyline that happens in the main comics. It’s not the story of Sandman, it’s exactly what the title calls it, an overture, like that bit before the musical or opera that sets the mood for what’s to come.

The Sandman is a difficult thing to get right, and yet Neil Gaiman almost always does. And Overture is no different. Taking place immediately before the events of the first Sandman comic, and showing what it was that exhausted him so much that he was able to be captured in Preludes and Nocturnes, Overture shows us more of what Morpheus’s existence was like before the events of the main comic. No, it’s not exactly a business-as-usual story for him, but it shows how Dream was, and hints at what he will be over the course of the story.

And it manages to flesh out some backstory on Dream and the other Endless. Again, it does what a good prequel does: it isn’t something necessary to understand the main story, but it does change how you view the Endless and how they interact with each other. It’s a nice little tidbit for fans of the series to see parts of their lives that we didn’t really have any reason to suspect that they had, and to see them interact in ways differently than we expect.

Best Video Game: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

[Fallout 4 might rank higher if I’d played more of it.]

Look, I feel as if this game has become a meme with how glitchy it is, and how it wasn’t that great to begin with. But guess what? Screw you guys, this game was THE SHIZ when it came out, and it’s a game that I can keep going back to over and over again and still have loads of fun and adventures that I didn’t have before.

For the past ten years, just about every RPG and open world game has been desperately trying to recapture the magic that Skyrim managed. No, this game didn’t invent open world games, or sidequests, or armor customization, or factions or fantasy RPGs. But they made the big, made it the mainstream game in a way that they weren’t before. Every game and their mother was trying to tell a story like that. And to be fair, some of them did manage to become successful. But Skyrim, man, for all its flaws I think it’s one of my favorites, and I think it’s the RPG that still evokes this sense of wonder from me that very few games ever did. Let’s be clear: the video game world would not be the way it is if it weren’t for Skyrim. The fact that I can find a Let’s Play of someone’s grandmother playing Skyrim I think is a good indicator of the way that this was one of the many things that brought fantasy into the mainstream of popular culture.

And you know, I get to fight dragons and giants and mammoths and shoot lightning out of my hands and build houses and kill vampires. That’s more than I generally ask for in a video game.

Best LEGO Game: LEGO Batman 3: Beyond Gotham

This also might be the best superhero game, but Batman: Arkham City also ranks pretty high up there.

[Also LEGO Star Wars II might have made this list if it came out in the past decade and not while I was in high school.]

LEGO Marvel Superheroes is insanely good, okay? Flying around NYC as Iron Man and up to the helicarrier is something that’s hard to beat. And LEGO DC Supervillains is pretty awesome. But in terms of sheer scale, in terms of ambition, and in terms of cool characters and powers and fun little Easter Eggs, I don’t know if any of the LEGO games match up.

Some awesome things in LEGO Batman 3: lazers. Adam West. Shapeshifting. Plastic Man. Music Meister. The Legion of Doom. Interplanetary travel. Parachuting from aircraft. Superspeed. The Watchtower. Punching Braniac in the face. And yeah, sure, there are some things that other games in the franchise do better; for instance, hearing Conan talk over and over again can be really annoying whenever you enter a new area or pass him. But this game is, I think, still the greatest in the series for how all-out insane it gets sometimes, how much you can do, how much content they pack into a LEGO game. It has more superheroes than I ever expected to be playable in a game and I cannot help but love it for that alone.

Best Shooter: Halo 4

Hey remember when Bungie said they didn’t want to do deep lore or give Master Chief a personality? Well 343 says “BUMP THAT!” and game a deep personal arc about Chief’s relationship with Cortana, an AI that has a deteriorating mind after years of service. And they’re stranded on a faraway planet. And this ancient alien god thing woke up and wants to destroy humanity.

Good stuff!

Halo 4 decided to add enemy types that challenged you in different ways; if you don’t take out the Promethean Watchers, for instance, they might revive the Promethean Knights that you took down. And don’t even think about using grenades around them; they’ll just hurl them back at you. And there’s Forerunner architecture and design out the wazoo; yes, they were present in previous games in the series, but now they’re here in full force, especially with the new Forerunner weapons you can try out.

But more interestingly, I really like that this game takes a good hard look at the story. What does Master Chief’s upbringing and the war do to him, psychologically speaking? How far is he willing to go to save Cortana? What the heck is wrong with the people who decided that kidnapping children was a good way to start a super soldier program? And did we really expect a conflict to end just because we killed the guy in charge?

I liked the story, I liked the gameplay, and I liked the design. And it was much more than I ever expected from Halo.

Best Assassin’s Creed: Assassin’s Creed: Odyssey

Alright you know that Assassin’s Creed was going to make it in here somewhere. And I still have a soft spot in me for Assassin’s Creed III, and Black Flag was also really good, even if it didn’t include Puerto Rico. And I love the character dynamics of Syndicate. But Odyssey? Look, this game is freaking Awesome, even if its place in the overall narrative doesn’t make that much sense. But I blame that on Origins, which has a weak story and retcons the origins of the Assassins.

I’ve been lamenting for years the lack of fantastical stories set in ancient Greece. And yes, technically this one is more science-fiction than fantasy, but it hits all the right buttons and all the right story beats for me to enjoy. It’s got family drama, an evil cult, loads of humor, a touch of mythology, and loads and loads of sword fights. And content out the wazoo; Lord knows there’s so much content, that even long after finishing the game I can turn it on and find myself some mercenary jobs and find something to do. 

I’m on the fence on whether this is my favorite Assassin’s Creed ever; after all, I still really like Assassin’s Creed 3. Story-wise I think AC3 still wins, though Odyssey’s gameplay and graphics are a lot more polished, there’s much more to do, and I think it’s a lot more fun to play in the long run. So I’m giving it to Odyssey.

Best Story for a Game: Horizon Zero Dawn

HOLY FUDGE YOU FIGHT GIANT ROBOT DINOSAURS WITH A BOW AND ARROW!

I urge you, play this game. The story, the design, the gameplay, the characters--it’s all really good. Someone decided to take the plot and character beats of a Chosen One-centered high fantasy novel and put it in a post-apocalyptic setting. This very easily could be a grungy dystopia, and instead it’s one of the most colorful and uplifting video games I’ve played in ages, with writing that’s sharp, direct, and also surprisingly subtle.

Horizon Zero Dawn just feels right. I remember starting the game and immediately being awed by the story and the characters that inhabit it. You’re invested the second the game starts, even if it takes a while to figure how the world got the way it did. And the player doesn’t feel bad because of it; there’s so much care and detail put into the world as it is at the time of the game that you don’t feel too much in a rush to find out what happened to make the world the way it is in Aloy’s time.

Every detail in the design is thoughtful and intricate. Every major character has an interesting backstory. Every Machine has a purpose to it. And Aloy, a headstrong brave of the Nora tribe trying to find out where she came from and what her place in the world is. There’s not a stupid romance arc, there aren’t annoying characters, there’s a girl on a mission in a strange and exciting world that’s full of giant robots.

Best Surprisingly Good Game: Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor

Jedi Fallen Order could have made this one, as could have LEGO Batman 3. This game… alright, pro-tip, don’t play this on Xbox 360 because the game isn’t built for it. You’ll get a loading screen every time you close the menu (that’s not an exaggeration).  But in terms of actual gameplay? It’s good. It’s alarmingly good. Mind you, combat is pretty heavily cribbed from the Batman: Arkham games, but with, like, swords.

And let’s be real here: tone-wise, this doesn’t fit very well in the lore of Middle-Earth (and let’s not even get into the canon issues). The idea of a man possessed by a wraith and getting superpowers only kind of fits with the Middle-Earth canon? Barely? That game makes up for it though by being loads of fun. And to top it all off, it gave us the Nemesis System, which means that every time you die, it’s incorporated into the gameplay. A random mook kills you? Now he has a name and a promotion, and every time you encounter one another in the game’s world you have a new Nemesis, and he might go out of his way to hunt you down. And he can become more powerful if he kills you or beats other Orcs.

This makes every playthrough unique, and personal, because you get a personal Nemesis that might interrupt your missions, or refuse to stay dead, and this leads to creative strategies and play styles. Even with the limitations of a game system that it didn’t play too well on, this made Shadow of Mordor a surprisingly fun game to play, and I imagine it was even better on Xbox One and PS4.

Best Band: Pentatonix

I’m not a music guy, so I can’t talk too much about bands or styles of music or songs. That’s not my field. So this is the only music mention I can do on this list. But it’s a good one! Pentatonix was formed with the explicit intention of being the most famous a capella group in the world, and unless we count the one from Pitch Perfect (which we shouldn’t because they’re fictional) they may have succeeded. 

Covering everything from pop songs to tunes from Broadway, Pentatonix is one of my favorite bands (although to be fair, I don’t have a lot of favorite bands).There is a certain level of energy they add to music that I don’t get from a lot of cover bands or even mainstream artists. Or maybe I have weird tastes in music, I don’t know. What I do know is that I’m always willing to check out their performances and albums.

And they do Christmas albums! And Christmas specials!

They’re fun, they’re fun to listen to, they’re fun to dance to, and they managed to accomplish exactly what they set out to do.

---

And we’re done! That’s it. I’m sure I can come up with some more favorites if I stop and think real hard about it, but for now I’ll leave you to this list. Stay safe out there during this virus!

Saturday, March 7, 2020

Best of the Last Decade: Part 2

It’s been a week, guys, but I have weekend plans and so I have high hopes for how this Saturday’s going to turn out, if for no other reason then I’m planning a trip to 2nd and Charles so things should turn out okay.

I’ve also been watching a bit of Castlevania and Locke & Key, the latter because I just finished the main comic series and I wanted to get to that series as quickly as I could.

Best Standalone Book: The Priory of the Orange Tree by Samantha Shannon

I just finished this one this past week, and before that it was going to go to Redshirts by John Scalzi (Star Trek parodies for the win!). Which is also great! I also think it’s worth noting that I don’t read that many standalone books. And if I remembered more of Uprooted by Naomi Novik, then it might have had a good chance at this spot.

But epic fantasy man! Which Uprooted also is, but Priory is a globe-spanning eight hundred page epic that seeks to tell something similar to a Saint George-type story, except driven by female characters in a fantasy world. It’s not a perfect novel, I think--the love story felt a bit underdeveloped at first, in my opinion. But it’s darn good. A self-contained story about facing an oncoming threat where people from all over the world must unite or die in the face of seemingly unstoppable evil, The Priory of the Orange Tree is a great novel that tells the story it sets out to tell without leaving any loose ends dangling.

Also it has dragons! Dragons out the wazoo! Chinese dragons! Japanese dragons! European dragons! Wyverns! 

Best Finale: The Shepherd’s Crown by Terry Pratchett

And possibly the saddest finale. It doesn’t feel as polished as some of Pratchett’s other novels, but The Shepherd’s Crown wraps up Tiffany Aching’s story in a way that feels just right. And it felt especially touching for me too; it was through the Tiffany Aching stories, and The Wee Free Men that I got my first introduction into the Discworld books, so knowing that the final book in the series for all time was a wrap-up for that was… something.

Pratchett sets off the story with the death of one of the most beloved of his characters, and bringing back some longtime foes, the author doesn’t really slow down from there. It’s a the kind of story that feels like a final story for the series: one in which a young character has finished her process of growing up, and taking the place that she needs to not only to protect her world, but also for herself and her self-realization. Because that’s where she was always meant to be from the beginning.

If there was ever a finale that will make you cry, it is this one.

Best Unfinished Work: The Dinosaur Lords by Victor Milan

The webcomic The Fox Sister is also pretty up there. But this is yet another work by a deceased author. Milan (and there should be an accent over the ‘a’ but I don’t know how to do that in Google Docs) passed away after releasing the third novel. 

The first book is basically Game of Thrones with dinosaurs. Which is AWESOME. Set in a world suspiciously like ours in the middle ages, The Dinosaur Lords asks the all-important question of: what if knights rode dinosaurs? And the story could have stopped at that, but instead he also wraps it up with international politics, magic, religious conflict, the Fae, zombies, and also some weird robot archangel things? I’m a bit unclear on that last one.

This could have just been a goofy fantasy series, and there are some scenes where it definitely comes across that way, to its own detriment. But overall, it’s a solid epic fantasy series and I’m sad to see that it’ll never be finished. Especially since the ending of the second book contains one of the greatest final duels I have ever seen in fiction. And look, if you’re not interested in knights riding dinosaurs, I don’t know what to tell you.

Best Nonfiction: March by John Lewis and Andrew Aydin, illustrated by Nate Powell

Hey, what if someone did a comic explaining the Civil Rights movement? Well chill, ‘cause Senator John Lewis decided to do exactly that. This comic displays that a comic doesn’t just need to tell outrageous stories to be an effective medium; March instead goes through John Lewis’s life, and showing how he got involved with the Civil Rights movement.

I’m not one who usually reads nonfiction, and definitely not usually in the form of comics. But March just works, and it’s effective. Telling a biography of a social movement could very easily be boring, but this isn’t; it’s not just because the framing device connecting it to the presentish day (specifically, Lewis attending the inauguration of Barack Obama, thus displaying how far Civil Rights has come, though by no means at the end goal yet), but also because it’s a personal story. We see Lewis’s life growing up, his ideals being formed, and how he met many of the big name Civil Rights leaders.

If you’re ever curious how to do a good nonfiction comic, or if you’re interested in the history of African-American rights, it’s worth checking out.

Best Comic Book Movie: Kingsman: The Secret Service

I heavily considered putting Avengers here, but ultimately I thought that Kingsman (and I mean the first one; there’s something off about The Golden Circle that doesn’t sit quite right with me) deserved this spot because of a few reasons:

A) It helped bring back actually good action sequences, admittedly in an over-stylized way.

B) It was also a really good science-fiction spy movie that plays a bit with expectations and themes, such as actually having death be seen as a horrific thing.

C) It’s really funny.

It’s a very English movie, I realized upon rewatching, and it is, at times, very silly. But it’s one of the most unique big budget action movies to be released in the last decade, and it’s definitely the most memorable comic book movie by virtue of sheer panache. 

Best Art Book: Assassin’s Creed: The Complete Visual History by Matthew Miller

I really like Assassin’s Creed, as will probably become obvious later on in this list. So when they released an art book explaining the decisions behind the design and art style of the games, along with plenty of pieces of concept art (which I also love in any form), I really had to get my hands on it. So now I’ve got this lovely book full of concept art depicting guys and gals in hoods at different points in history.

Not only does the concept art show how ideas and characters developed over time, but why their design went the way it did. For instance, Ubisoft wasn’t sure they going to carry the eagle theme through the entire series; when designing Ezio, they heavily considered giving him a raven or crow theme. And Templars aren’t just given crosses out the yin-yang, they’re also often designed with boxes and squares in general shape and fashion choices, because those are very orderly and reflects their ideals.

Best Radio Drama: BBC’s Neverwhere

On some days I think that Neverwhere is my favorite of Neil Gaiman’s books. But it wasn’t released this past decade. That being said there was a very good radio drama with an excellent cast (James McAvoy as Richard! Natalie Dormer as Door! Benedict Cumberbatch as Islington!) and every time it’s free on the BBC Radio website I find myself listening to it.

The story was apparently motivated by Gaiman asking: what if your life didn’t turn out the way you planned, and you go on a quest to get everything you’ve ever wanted back? And would it really be worth it, in the end? This is of course told through a Scotsman accidentally falling into London Below where there are monsters, mercenaries, magic, and also an angel chilling out deep underground.

Also, pro-tip: all of Neverwhere makes much more sense if you have a basic familiarity with London. I remember thinking it was good; after visiting London and taking a course on the history of London and the literature it inspired, I think it’s downright amazing in how many little Easter Eggs there are, and how much detail is put into the names and characters.

Best Science-Fiction: Inception 


Alright guys Inception got a reputation for being a really complex and hard-to-follow film, which it’s not, really, so I understand that if that was your introduction to the movie it maybe didn’t live up to the hype. But it is a great movie and does what a really great sci-fi movie does: works with one piece of technology beyond what we have now and builds the story around it. In this case, it’s a device that lets you go into people’s dreams. 

It’s a bit like a reverse heist movie in someone’s brain, because instead of trying to steal something, they’re trying to plant something: specifically, trying to get someone to plant an idea in someone’s head, and if Cobb pulls it off, he’ll get to finally go home and meet up with his family. It’s carried by a phenomenal cast who are giving this movie their all, so that you find yourself liking most of the named characters who appear on screen.

And this movie has a ton of things that keep adding layer upon layer to its construction, though you don’t need any of those to fully enjoy the movie. Like hey, the main character’s name is Cobb, an old-fashioned word for a spider, and he weaves these elaborate dream worlds that people are stuck in? And the student that helps them design the perfect dream that’s like a maze is named Ariadne like the Greek mythological character?

….intertextuality is kind of my jam.

Best Animation: Loving Vincent

...I was talking about intertextuality being my jam, yes?

I want to qualify that this is not the best animated film, but it was the best animation; though the animation in Klaus was also noteworthy and worth taking a look at. And also The Peanuts! But back to this one, because the point of this film was not just to do a character study of Vincent Van Gogh, but also to make the movie look like a Van Gogh painting. 

I’ve seen several critics claim that the story was kind of dull; I didn’t get that. But basically, we find a young man trying to discover everything he can about Vincent Van Gogh and what led to his suicide. It’s something like a mystery, but it’s more of a inquiry about mental health and art and how the two connect. Because Vincent Van Gogh was not a mentally or emotionally healthy man and the film doesn’t shy away from that.

But gosh look, it looks like a painting! There are films that have shot composition or design that look like paintings or drawn art, especially in animation, but taking an entire movie and making it look like Van Gogh’s paintings? Down to scenery, character design, and choice in colors? That’s a brilliant move and I’m happy to see it pulled off.

I loved Coco to death (and so should you, go see it), but I think this one should have won Best Animated Picture for its contribution to animation.

Best Action Film Series: John Wick

The basic Plot of the John Wick series is kind of dull. But dang do these movies still push all the right buttons because it’s all so cool. The fight scenes are amazingly choreographed, but not to the point that they’re overly stylized like in Kingsman. They’re rough, and harsh, and often regress to people just beating each other with what they have handy. The worldbuilding is well-delivered and incredibly awesome: this idea that there’s this secret world of criminals and assassins covertly run by “the High Table” with which no one can argue. And the movies have several colorful and interesting characters. Yeah, you may hate some of them, but you’re meant to hate the ones you hate.

In an age when Hollywood became obsessed with nostalgic properties and superhero films, it’s refreshing to see an original series of action movies that relies on providing enjoyable action sequences and a straightforward story. John Wick is an ex-assassin. A Russian mob prince kills his dog. Wick goes and kills everyone because of it. And it is absolutely lovely to watch.

And storywise, that’s kind of all there is to it. But the sheer number of fight scenes, the style of the fights, the aesthetics of the secret world of the High Table, and the colorful cast make this one of the best action series I’ve ever seen.

Best Animated Movie: Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

The LEGO Movie was under consideration for a while, and there were a few days where I thought this was going to go to Song of the Sea. Both of those are great and you should check those out. But in the end, it goes to Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse for sheer, absolute joy of seeing a CGI animated film that’s as good as this movie is. Not only does it have spectacular animation, in an attempt to look like a comic book, it has an exquisite story that proves why Spider-Man is one of the most durable characters in popular culture: because given the chance, it could be anyone behind that mask.

I did not expect this movie to be this good. I remember seeing the teaser trailer and thinking that this was probably going to be something like a straight-to-DVD movie that was somehow getting a theatrical release. When full trailers came out, I guess I thought it looked good, but as a good kid’s movie in the way LEGO Batman was (and that’s a great movie too, please watch that). I wasn’t prepared for how amazing this movie was, how much it was a celebration of Spider-Man, how it had lovable heroes and an understandable, if still dickish, villain.

And how this movie, from its acting, to its animation, to its style, to its script, to its music, to its coloration, to its message was all just so good. This won the Oscar when it came out, and it absolutely deserved it. 

Best Stop-Motion Animation: ParaNorman

Of the LAIKA films Boxtrolls and Kubo and the Two Strings are good, alright? I assume that Missing Link is as well, but I haven’t seen it. And outside of LAIKA, The Little Prince is pretty darn great too! But ParaNorman is, I humbly think, the best of the bunch. As an original story about a boy who doesn’t quite fit in because he talks to ghosts, ParaNorman is an unforgettable story about acceptance and what happens when society pushes some people to the side.

Also it’s a zombie movie for kids, which isn’t… I don’t know if there are a lot of those. Like I know Disney Channel is doing them now I guess but that’s kind of different.

ParaNorman has the added challenge, in the animation department, of making ghost characters? Which sounds fine until you remember that this film is stop-motion, and so the fact that they make moving characters who are also see-throughable is mind-blowing. And yes, not knowing how it was done it’s possible that CGI was used to aid in this effect, but it doesn’t look out of place and fits with the rest of the animation smoothly, which is impressive as all get out. 

By all means, look up all of LAIKA’s movies, but if you have to prioritize please pick ParaNorman.

Best Popcorn Flick: The Magnificent Seven

What if I told you there was a remake of a classic Western film (which itself is an American remake of a Japanese film but NOT THE POINT!), with fantastic action scenes, an ethnically diverse cast of awesome characters, and a great score which was the last thing the composer did before he died? 

Yeah, Magnificent Seven. And it’s brilliant.

You don’t generally expect a Western to have a diverse cast, but this one does. The titular Seven are: a black government agent, a white gambler, a white ex-Confederate sharpshooter, an Asian knife man, a Mexican outlaw, a white frontiersman, and a Native American loner. Sadly, not all of them get enough backstory, but you get enough that you have a feel for their characters, and all of them have awesome moments and lines.

[And hey, if you watch, there's not a lot of ‘spray enemies with a hail of bullets’ thing. Just about every single shot the protagonists make hits the intended target. Which is another thing you don’t see a lot in movies.]

There were some great popcorn flicks this past decade. This is the one that really struck me as being a great one that I could watch its scenes over and over again just because it’s so much fun.

---

And that’s it for part two! Next week will be part three, which I fully expect to be the last one.